Tuesday, April 08, 2008
If atheists get to repeat themselves...
...then so do I.
The difference is that I am forced into it. I ask a question, the atheist begs the question. I explain why it's begging the question and ask him to answer it again. He then repeats the same "answer". Et cetera.
Consider the latest offering from JeffPerado. His thinking is so muddled and shallow that I almost cringe to link to him, but what the heck. He is trying to respond to my cheery, cheeky Christmas scenario.
Well done, JeffPerado, you've successfully begged the question. Hard. Again and again. One wonders whether it could ever be begged again after such an enervation. Sadly, it's what I expected.
You simply refuse to engage (or are incapable of engaging) the question at hand.
This is what I mean when I say that atheism is the usurpation of God's rule. You've taken on the role of Arbiter of Morality.
-They would have a good reason, their girls were being raped.
Prove it's a good reason.
-Now is war moral? If your self-preservation is on the line then yes.
Prove it's moral if your self-preservation is on the line.
-Clearly we have a situation where war is moral.
-They were following a "moral" practice and now are fighting for their lives because of it. Is that moral? No. Because win or lose, they lose valuable resources:
Prove that losing valuable resources is immoral.
Prove that human resources are indeed valuable.
-Morality is sick when it comes from any supposed supernatural outside-of-human-experience source
Because you say so?
-I don't make these rules or decide morality.
Actually, it looks like you're doing precisely that.
-Society does, and it does so only after time and (human) experience determines it as moral.
Also, which society? At what time? How long does it take? What % of people?
Tkalim's society, I remind you, supports this practice 100%, unanimously. So it's right to do this. Right?
-In other words, would you Rhology, allow your daughters to be raped if God ordained it, but would call it immoral if some other god ordained it, both being via supernatural origins.
God has never ordained rape. You are very ignorant and it is showing, seriously.
Nor would God ever ordain rape. Your premises are bad, so the question is vapor.